Companies with Largest Reserves Have Poorest Governance
MADRID, Spain — Petrobras is the world’s most sustainable oil/gas company according to the 5th annual oil/gas ranking by the sustainability research and rating firm Management & Excellence (M&E, Madrid & Sao Paulo).
The M&E ranking, marketed with Oil&Gas Journal Online, measures oil/gas companies’ compliance with 387 accepted international standards in sustainability, corporate governance, social responsibility, ethics and transparency. The guidelines are taken from institutions such as SEC, Sarbanes-Oxley, national laws, Dow Jones Sustainability Index, OECD, industry benchmarks, GRI, ILO, ISO, EITI, reserves accounting, Global Compact, Millennium Goals, and others. The annual study is considered the most detailed benchmark on sustainability in the industry.
Petrobras, once known for sinking oil rigs and strikes, was re-elected to the Dow Jones Sustainability Index, an indicator where StatoilHydro holds the industry record of 79 points. Petrobras’ Board consists of all independent directors, except the CEO. The Brazilian company’s “Zero Hunger Program” entered into 18,000 partnerships helping nearly 11 million people over the past four years. BP rebounded following the 2005 explosion in its Texas City complex, oil spills in Alaska and the resignation of its former CEO Lord Browne, investing $1.7 billion in its U.S. operations for “integrity and reliability.”
Companies with the poorest governance and sustainability practices generally controlled the largest oil/gas reserves. The three state corporations PDVSA, Saudi Aramco and Abu Dhabi NOC in part scored zero in governance but together control 430 billion barrels of oil, compared with ConocoPhilips’ 9,4 billion or ExxonMobil’s 22.7 billion.
Most Sustainable Oil Companies 2008 (compliance scores)
1. Petrobras 92.25% 2. Total 91.21% 3. BP; StatoilHydro 89.15% 4. (tie at #3) 5. Shell 87.86% 6. ENI 78.55% 7. Repsol 74.68% 8. OMV 73.39% 9. Chevron 72.87% 10. ConocoPhilips 72.35% 11. ExxonMobil 67.96% 12. Pemex 66.93% 13. Marathon 66.67% 14. Lukoil 55.81% 15. ENAP 40.31% 16. Gazprom 40.05% 17. Petrochina 37.47% 18. ADNOC 31.78% 19. Saudi Aramco 29.72% 20. PDVSA 12.92%
A second M&E study ranks 5 major players in the oil/gas service business which are following in the footsteps of their bigger clients. Yet only Schlumberger and Halliburton achieve above-average compliance levels, with Schlumberger the only member of the Dow Jones Sustainability Index.
Most Sustainable Oil/Gas SERVICE Companies 2008
1. Schlumberger 72.68% 2. Halliburton 65.92% 3. Baker Hughes 47.04% 4. Cameron 34.93% 5. Weatherford 30.14%
M&E: Telephone (0034) 91-5902950
[tags]Management and Excellence SA[/tags]